MLB: 2026 AL Cy Young Winner Predictions

Who Will Win the 2026 AL Cy Young Award?

The American League's top pitching prize remains wide open heading into 2026. This Polymarket prediction market lets traders and fans weigh in on which starter will claim the Cy Young, with outcomes ranging from consensus favorites to long-shot candidates. The market closes on Nov 12, 2026, giving participants nearly a full season to refine their forecasts based on real performance data.

Market-Implied Favorites for the 2026 AL Cy Young

Cam Schlittler commands the highest implied probability at 61%, reflecting market confidence in his Cy Young credentials. Dylan Cease follows at 20%, while Parker Messick holds 4%. The remaining contenders—Jacob deGrom, Tarik Skubal, George Kirby, Bryan Woo, and Joe Ryan—each carry single-digit probabilities, signaling they're viewed as unlikely winners by the crowd.

What Could Shift the 2026 Cy Young Race

In-season performance will reshape these odds significantly. A pitcher's ERA, strikeout rate, and win-loss record over the coming months will either validate the current market consensus or create openings for undervalued competitors. Injuries to top contenders, surprise breakout seasons from lower-probability names, or statistical races that tighten dramatically down the stretch all have the power to move prices and alter the implied landscape heading toward November.

More: read our Polymarket review, compare the best prediction market apps, or bet on sports with a US sportsbook.